2023

• Megan (Warren) Fry, Class of 2002 (volleyball/softball)
• R. Thomas Renner, Class of 2006 (wrestling/football/cross country)
• Michael Kasperski, Class of 2007 (golf/basketball/baseball)
• Kevin Sheppard, Class of 1982 (honorary inductee)

2022

• Kelsey (Bowers) Closson, Class of 2005 (volleyball)
• Jack Versau II, Class of 2007 (basketball/golf)
• McKenzie Zinn, Class of 2012 (volleyball/tennis)
• Becca (Schott) Bobo, Class of 2013 (cross country/track)
• Logan Targgart, Class of 2015 (football/basketball/track)
• Brendan Spangler, Class of 2016 (baseball/basketball/football)
• Nathan Waterbury, Class of 2016 (tennis/basketball/golf)

2021

• NO CEREMONY - COVID-19 Pandemic

2020

• Tina (Payne) Scheidler, Class of 1986 (softball/volleyball/basketball/coach)
• Steve Long, Class of 1996 (cross country/track)
• Tara (Marquart) Wiacek, Class of 1998 (volleyball/basketball/softball)
• Alice Haylett, Class of 1940 (honorary inductee)

2019

• Kylie Dudek, Class of 2013 (gymnastics)
• BreeAnn Spangler, Class of 2013 (volleyball/basketball)
• Eric Beckhusen, Class of 1988 (football/basketball/track)
• Pat Lewis, Class of 1965 (honorary inductee)

2018

• Troy Frick, Class of 1985 (football/basketball/baseball)
• Gordon Mosher III, Class of 1996 (football/track)
• Ashley Burkhardt, Class of 2012 (volleyball/basketball/softball)
• The scheduled 2018 induction ceremony was cancelled due to inclement weather. These Hall of Fame members were formally recognized together with the 2019 induction class, above.

2017

• Kristie (Sexton) Clark, Class of 2008 (volleyball, basketball, tennis)
• Seth Szafranski, Class of 2010 (basketball, baseball)
• Querubin Dubois, Class of 2011 (basketball, softball)
• Tyler Guzy, Class of 2011 (football, basketball, baseball)
• Wayne Case, Honorary Inductee

2016

• Keely (Gruner) Beemer, Class of 2007 (volleyball/basketball/softball)
• Corey Post, Class of 2007 (football/basketball/baseball)
• Cam Holicki, Class of 2010 (soccer/basketball/track)
• Cassie Krenzalek, Class of 2010 (cheer/gymnastics/track)

2015

• Miranda (Robison) Lewis, Class of 2004 (volleyball/basketball/softball)
• During the 2015 induction ceremony, the main gym at Coldwater High School was rechristened the Coach Floyd Eby Gymnasium.

2014

• Aaron Tagert, Class of 2001 (football/basketball/track)
• Tom Sweitzer (wrestling coach)
• Coldwater Township Sunrise Rotary Club (honorary inductees)

2013

• Nick Longstreet, Class of 2003 (wrestling)
• Sara Sickels, Class of 2005 (basketball/volleyball/track)
• Jay Bilsborrow, Class of 2006 (cross country/track)
• Roger Fuller (coach of 4 state champion golf teams)

2012

• Julie (Schorfhaar) Klein, Class of 1982 (track/basketball/gymnastics/volleyball)
• Bob Bates, Class of 1990 (cross country/track)
• Doug Mitmesser, Class of 1955 (football/cross country/basketball/baseball/golf coach)

2011

• Abraham "A.J." Demond, Class of 2001 (bowling)
• Megan (Petzko) Sweet, Class of 2004 (golf)
• Hal & Lillian Creal (honorary inductees)

2009

• Amy (Porter) VanAken, Class of 2002 (volleyball/basketball/softball)
• Tim Porter, Class of 1989 (football/basketball/baseball)
• Doug Howard, Class of 1999 (tennis/football/basketball)
• Jennifer (Petzko) Knowles, Class of 2000 (golf)

2007

• Jana Harding, Class of 1983 (basketball/softball)
• Erick Shaffer, Class of 1996 (basketball)

2006

• Rob Shook, Class of 1981 (football/baseball)
• Steve Cherry, Class of 1996 (basketball)
• Francis "Pat" Lowe (baseball coach)

2003

• Amber Crenshaw, Class of 1996
• Susan Moore, Class of 1977
• Jason Gilchrist, Class of 1995
• Bill Welke, MLB Umpire (honorary inductee)

2002

• Tina Boester, Class of 1992
• Amanda Fuller, Class of 1992
• Nate Gilchrist, Class of 1995
• Russ Hickey, Class of 1993

2000

• Shannon Crabtree, Class of 1994
• Kevin Cox, Class of 1973
• Chuck Neutz, Class of 1981
• WTVB Radio (honorary inductee)

1999

• LaBeth Page, Class of 1979
• Brent Mohr, Class of 1994
• Jeff Kellogg, MLB Umpire (honorary inductee)

1998

• Stacy Duncan, Class of 1993
• Joy Strawser, Class of 1991
• Jason Edwards, Class of 1992
• Zach Witte, Class of 1994
• Coach Floyd Eby (honorary inductee)

1997

• Joan Monroe, Class of 1989
• Andrew Schorfhaar, Class of 1990

1996

• Dawn (Mariott) Timm, Class of 1989
• Jeff Schorfhaar, Class of 1987
• Eric Goodwin (honorary inductee)

1995

• Tim Kellogg, Class of 1987
• Jill Strawser, Class of 1989
• Bud Barnes, Coldwater Daily Reporter (honorary inductee)

1994

• Rick DeMarr, Class of 1975
• Sgt. Kristine Post, Class of 1985
• Warner "Skip" Davenport (honorary inductee)

1993

• Cathy Page, Class of 1981
• Brian Marteen, Class of 1986
• Dr. David and Del Rubley (honorary inductees)

1992

• Heidi Olsen, Class of 1987
• Mike Post, Class of 1978
• Dr. Don Paarlberg (honorary inductee)

1991

• Bret Norton, Class of 1982
• Martha (Loud) Capestany, Class of 1978
• Scott Brayton, IndyCar Driver (special pro sports award)

1990

• Becky (Howe) Smith, Class of 1983
• Richard Uhl (honorary inductee)
• Tim Welke, MLB Umpire (special pro sports award)

1989

• Chris Kellogg, Class of 1976
• Bill Crotty III, Class of 1984
• Tina Straw, Class of 1980

1988

• Mark Kellogg, Class of 1978
• Quinn Berry, Class of 1969
• Ann (Harding) Gibson, Class of 1979
• C. Lester Luce (honorary inductee)

1987

• Mary Jo Henderson, Class of 1976
• William Klotz, Class of 1971
• Jim Bilsborrow, Class of 1968
• Tom Newman, Class of 1978
• William Nettleman (honorary inductee)

1986

• Chris Dorr, Class of 1978
• Mary Blaskie, Class of 1978
• Ron Curtis, Class of 1965
• Dale Dean (honorary inductee)

1985

• Dennis Scheidler, Class of 1970
• Rick Gates, Class of 1976
• Cathy Heator, Class of 1978
• Stanley Borden Sr. (honorary inductee)

1984

• Mike Sowles, Class of 1973
• Rich Warner Ozmun, Class of 1975
• Darwin LaBelle, Class of 1968
• John Keeslar (honorary inductee)

1983

• Robert Mosier, Class of 1967
• Carol McLaughlin, Class of 1972
• Bertrand Grigg (honorary inductee)
• Sally Childs (honorary inductee)

1982

• Mary Hodgman Renshaw, Class of 1923
• Dick Martinson, Class of 1964
• Ron LaBelle, Class of 1970
• Paul Cosgrove, Class of 1964

1981

• Jack Tighe, Class of 1948
• Harold "Bud" Raymond, Class of 1951
• Kermit Dennis (honorary inductee)

1980

• William Fry
• Joe Lopez, Class of 1975
• Marvin Rosenberg, Class of 1949

1979

• Robert Mahaffey, Class of 1939
• Charlie Bill Gibson, Class of 1966
• Howard May, Class of 1954
• Dr. James Bailey (honorary inductee)

1978

• Oscar Renshaw, Class of 1924
• Alan Swain, Class of 1947
• Terry Trott, Class of 1967

1977

• Leroy Potter, Class of 1925
• Adolf Dillon, Class of 1931
• Mark Mann, Class of 1937
• Charles Wheeler, Class of 1938
• Dick Lynd, Class of 1939
• Rollie Gilbert, Class of 1947
• Bruce Buys, Class of 1960
• Clare Gruner, Class of 1922
• Max McConnell, Class of 1949
• Tom Sowles, Class of 1971
• Dr. Ken Olmstead, Class of 1922
• Seton Bovee (honorary inductee)

1976

• F. Leslie Treat, Class of 1963
• Harold "Red" Higgins, Class of 1921
• Alf Watson, Class of 1925
• Yale McCort, Class of 1927
• Olin McConnell, Class of 1927
• Floyd Raymond, Class of 1928
• Claude Rasey, Class of 1931
• Joe Newell, Class of 1931
• Eldon Bunce, Class of 1935
• Clayton Linton, Class of 1933
• Robert Richardson, Class of 1932
• Kid Bunce, Class of 1935
• Paul Weaver, Class of 1937
• Bryant VanAken, Class of 1938
• Gene Fry, Class of 1950
• Jim Rhodes, Class of 1950
• Dave Bennett, Class of 1952
• Larry Downs, Class of 1961

1975

• Ernie Vogt, Class of 1909
• Wes Wilbur, Class of 1911
• Max Holbrook, Class of 1924
• Lawrence Stewart, Class of 1928
• James Dillon, Class of 1931
• Tim Lynd, Class of 1932
• Harley Greenich, Class of 1939
• Bonnie Berry, Class of 1941
• Bill Newberry, Class of 1944
• Max Corless, Class of 1945
• Dean Murphy, Class of 1948
• LeRoy Cox, Class of 1949
• Carl Lewis, Class of 1949
• Fred Hobart, Class of 1954
• Paul Douglas, Class of 1957
• Forest Snow, Class of 1958
• Tom Smith, Class of 1961

1974

• Warner Van Aken, Class of 1911
• Carlton Tribby, Class of 1924
• Ralf Henton, Class of 1929
• Lloyd Green, Class of 1931
• Max Mannerow, Class of 1931
• Walt Marion, Class of 1934
• Bill Zabonick, Class of 1944
• Rex Corless, Class of 1950
• Eugene Sowles, Class of 1949
• Don Smith, Class of 1949
• Joe Grigg, Class of 1954
• Bill Timm, Class of 1958
• Dennis Waters, Class of 1964